Dear Miss Jameson,

We're Jew or Not Jew. Look, you now got a profile on our website. Congrats!

Jenna (can we call you Jenna?), we've read all about your conversion. You love your Jewish fiance. You're taking Hebrew lessons. You're cooking Kosher food. You're even on an Israeli reality show documenting all of it. That's terrific!

Here's what worries us, Jenna. It's your past. Yes, we had to go there! Sorry.

Dear Jenna, you say that you turned a new leaf. You say, let bygones be bygones. You say that we shouldn't judge you based on past transgressions. We sure hope you're right.

But Jenna... We can't get past one thing:

You used to describe yourself as a "devout Catholic"...